55 Highlights 35 Differences 7 Reactions 0 Likes

Fender P-51 vs Shure SM58: 55 Highlights & 35 Differences — So, Which Microphone Actually Works Better

See which mic offers enhanced vocal performance and professional certification for your recording needs. What sets Fender P-51 and Shure SM58 apart in the music world? We looked at their connection interface, power source, stand/tripod & warranty and key features in this microphones showdown.

19 Points
Fender
Fender
Fender P-51
The Fender P-51 has been discontinued️. Our community last shared an update on December 10, 2025.
Fender P-51
72 Points
Shure SM58
vs

Highlights 159

No extras. Just what matters.
19 Points
vs
72 Points

Why is Fender P-51 better than Shure SM58 ?

Scroll down for more facts

Fender P-51 vs Shure SM58: A Dynamic Microphone Showdown

When it comes to dynamic handheld microphones tailored for live performances and instrument miking, the Fender P-51 and Shure SM58 stand as trusted options with a lot in common. Both models sport a cardioid polar pattern designed to capture focused audio, utilize wired XLR connections with detachable cables, and feature durable metal constructions fitted with adjustable stands and swivel mounts. 

They rely on passive power sources with transformerless designs and follow pressure gradient acoustic principles, ensuring reliability and solid sound capture during use. However, fundamental differences in dimensions, audio capabilities, onboard controls, and certifications mark distinctive paths in how each microphone best serves varied user needs.

Fender P-51: Durability and Simple Control for Instrumental Performances

The Fender P-51 sets itself apart with a larger presence, measuring 10 inches tall and weighing in at 1.6 pounds, compared to a more compact alternative. This robust metal body with a rugged metal finish and an internal shockmount ensures resilience during energetic on-stage use. It is tailored more toward instrument miking and live sound environments, featuring a large diaphragm capsule designed to capture rich, full-bodied sound with a frequency response spanning from 50 Hz to 15,000 Hz. The output impedance is rated at 600 ohms, allowing compatibility with various professional PA systems.

One handy feature of the P-51 is its built-in on/off switch, providing straightforward control during sets. While it lacks advanced voice isolation and proximity effect controls, its transformerless design aids in delivering clean sound without coloration. The package includes a stand, cables, a carrying case, and a mounting clip, with a solid 5-year warranty, demonstrating Fender’s confidence in durability and longevity. Priced attractively at around $39.99 at Guitar Center, the P-51 offers an affordable solution for musicians seeking reliable sound reproduction without extra frills.

The Shure SM58: The Gold Standard for Vocals and Broadcast

In contrast, the Shure SM58 shines as an iconic microphone known worldwide for its vocal clarity and professional versatility. Smaller and lighter, standing only 6.37 inches tall and weighing 0.65 pounds, it’s much easier to handle during extended vocal performances or podcasts. The SM58 features a 2-inch capsule and a revered maximum sound pressure level of 160 dB, making it capable of handling the loudest sound sources without distortion.

What truly differentiates the SM58 is its built-in gain control for nuanced audio adjustments and the incorporation of voice isolation and proximity effect controls. These attributes improve the microphone’s ability to reduce background noise and deliver crisp, focused vocals, making it a staple in studios, live broadcasts, and high-demand settings. Its robust metal build with a steel grill, internal foam damping, corrosion resistance, and drop resistance further enhance its ruggedness for touring professionals.

The SM58 package enriches the experience with a mounting clip, adapters, foam protective insert, carrying case, and a 2-year warranty, along with professional broadcast certifications and environmental compliances. All these qualities justify its higher price of around $99 at B&H Photo Video, reflecting a commitment to consistent studio-grade reliability.

A Quick Comparative Glance

The Fender P-51 wins points for budget-conscious artists needing a sturdy microphone optimized for instrumental and live stage use, complete with a convenient on/off switch and a reassuring 5-year warranty. Meanwhile, the Shure SM58 stands as a seasoned pro’s choice, excelling in vocal isolation, gain control, and certification for broadcast-level performance, all wrapped in a compact, durable design.

Bottom Line: Which Dynamic Mic Fits Your Needs?

If professional vocal performance, top-tier durability, and industry-renowned broadcast certifications are essential, the Shure SM58 remains unmatched despite its higher price point. On the other hand, for musicians and performers who require a dependable, straightforward dynamic microphone geared toward instruments and live gigs on a tight budget, the Fender P-51 delivers solid value and practical reliability.

Verdict

  • Winner: Shure SM58 – Its superior vocal clarity, built-in gain control, professional certifications, and rugged yet lightweight design make it the definitive choice for demanding users.
  • Runner-up: Fender P-51 – Offers robust build quality, simplicity, and an extended warranty at a highly affordable price, ideal for live instrument applications and budget-oriented buyers.

Comparisons 72

Two enter. One leaves your cart.

Price comparisons

(✱) Prices may be changed at any time without further notice.

Related comparisons 72

Because one duel is never enough.

Comparisons & Facts 159

Side by side. The numbers. The features. No drama.

This is more than specs — it’s a microphones face-off between Fender P-51 and Shure SM58 with features, user reviews, build feedback, and musician reactions.

General Information 18

Model Name

What is the model name?

58 Fender P-51 0 Votes P-51

52 Shure SM58 0 Votes SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Model Name

Model Name shows Fender P-51 versus Shure SM58, highlighting two distinct microphone models for customers choosing brand-specific features.

The specific product identifier from the manufacturer.

Country of Origin

What is the country of origin?

84 Fender P-51 0 Votes Japan

80 Shure SM58 0 Votes United States

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 is made in the USA, ensuring high-quality manufacturing and craftsmanship.

Manufacturing or design origin.

Gender Target

What is the gender target?

96 Fender P-51 0 Votes Unisex

90 Shure SM58 0 Votes Unisex

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Gender Target

Gender Target is Unisex for both, suitable for all users regardless of gender.

The marketing target by gender (if specified).

Product Type

What is the product type?

36 Fender P-51 0 Votes Dynamic

30 Shure SM58 0 Votes Dynamic

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Product Type

The Product Type for Fender P-51 is Dynamic and for Shure SM58 also Dynamic, indicating both are dynamic microphones suitable for similar use cases, ideal for those wanting robust dynamic microphones.

Defines the basic category of the microphone.

Form Factor

What is the form factor?

26 Fender P-51 0 Votes Handheld

40 Shure SM58 0 Votes Handheld

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone has a Handheld form factor, designed for easy use by vocalists or presenters on stage.

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

This handheld microphone is widely preferred for live vocal performances due to its portability and ease of use.

Describes the physical style of the microphone.

Polar Pattern Type

What is the polar pattern type?

71 Fender P-51 0 Votes Cardioid

50 Shure SM58 0 Votes Cardioid

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Polar Pattern Type

Polar Pattern Type is Cardioid for both microphones, focusing on sound sources from the front, ideal for live performances.

Identifies the default pickup pattern.

Color Options

What are the color options?

36 Fender P-51 0 Votes Black

70 Shure SM58 0 Votes Black

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Color Options

Color Options are Black for both instruments, offering a classic look preferred by many users.

Available product colors.

Recording Application Category

What recording applications is it best for?

71 Fender P-51 0 Votes Live

63 Shure SM58 0 Votes Studio, Live, Podcast, Broadcast, Streaming, Field Recording

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Recording Application Category

Recording Application Category is Live for Fender P-51 and extended Studio, Live, Podcast, Broadcast, Streaming, and Field Recording for Shure SM58, making Shure more versatile.

Specific contexts where the mic is best suited.

User Skill Level

What is the user skill level?

71 Fender P-51 0 Votes Intermediate, Professional

90 Shure SM58 0 Votes Professional

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

This microphone is designed for Intermediate,Professional users, offering features and performance suitable for experienced audio engineers and performers.

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

Preferred by professionals, the SM58's ease of use and high durability make it a great option for beginners as well.

Recommended audience expertise level.

Year of Release

What year was it released?

26 Fender P-51 0 Votes 2007

2 Shure SM58 1 Votes 1966

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

First released in 1966, the SM58 has become a standard in the industry, continuing to be popular for nearly 60 years.

Indicates when the microphone was launched.

Honestly, the Shure SM58 being released in 1966 and still being a standard says a lot about its timeless quality. The Fender P-51 from 2007 is newer but the SM58's legacy is unmatched.

See more

Series/Line

What series/line does it belong to?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

68 Shure SM58 0 Votes SM Series

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM Series includes several microphones, with the SM58 being the standout model for vocal performances.

Identifies the product line or collection the microphone belongs to.

Intended Use

What is the intended use?

59 Fender P-51 0 Votes Live, Instrument

57 Shure SM58 0 Votes Studio, Live, Podcast, Broadcast, Instrument, Streaming

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 is a versatile microphone suitable for a range of applications including live performances, podcasts, broadcasting, and instrument recording.

Describes the primary application area.

Dimensions & Weight 14

Weight

What is the weight?

1.6 lbs 0 Votes
Fender P-51
0.65 lbs 1 Votes
Shure SM58

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone has a weight of 1.6 lbs (0.73 kg), making it substantial yet manageable for handheld use.

The microphone’s physical weight.

The weight difference is pretty significant for me. The Shure SM58 is much lighter at 0.65 lbs compared to the Fender P-51's 1.6 lbs which really helps with portability.

See more

Depth

What is the depth?

5 inch 0 Votes
Fender P-51
2 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Depth

Depth is 5 inch (12.7 cm) for Fender P-51 and 2 inch (5.08 cm) for Shure SM58, showing P-51 is deeper, impacting handheld ergonomics.

The microphone’s overall depth.

Capsule Length

What is the capsule length?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

2.3 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Capsule Length

Capsule Length is unavailable for Fender P-51 and 2.3 inch (5.84 cm) for Shure SM58, useful for understanding microphone capsule size.

The length of the microphone capsule.

Height

What is the height?

10 inch 0 Votes
Fender P-51
6.37 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone has a height of 10 inch (25.4 cm), providing its overall vertical dimension.

The microphone’s overall height.

Cable Length

What is the cable length?

15 ft 0 Votes
Fender P-51

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The included cable has a length of 15 ft (4.57 m), providing ample reach for various setups.

Length of the included or integrated cable.

Mounting Thread Size

What is the mounting thread size?

96 Fender P-51 0 Votes 5/8"

70 Shure SM58 0 Votes 5/8"

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone uses a 5/8" mounting thread size, which is the industry standard for microphone stands.

The thread size for mounting compatibility.

Width

What is the width?

3 inch 0 Votes
Fender P-51
2 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The microphone’s overall width.

Package Width

What is the package width?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

5.5 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The shipping package’s width.

Package Depth

What is the package depth?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

2.5 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The shipping package’s depth.

Package Height

What is the package height?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

9 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The shipping package’s height.

Stand/Arm Length

What is the stand/arm length?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Maximum length of included stand or boom arm.

Capsule Diameter

What is the capsule diameter?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

2 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The diameter of the microphone capsule.

Audio Performance 29

Directionality

What is the directionality?

66 Fender P-51 0 Votes Cardioid

50 Shure SM58 0 Votes Unidirectional

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Directionality

Directionality is Cardioid for Fender P-51 and Unidirectional for Shure SM58, both focus on front sound capture.

General pickup orientation.

Max SPL

What is the maximum SPL?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

160 dB 1 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 is capable of handling high sound pressure levels (160 dB SPL), making it suitable for loud live performances without distortion.

The maximum loudness before distortion.

Handling loud sources is important for me, and the Shure SM58's max SPL of 160 dB is impressive. The Fender P-51 doesn't list this spec, making the SM58 the safer bet for high-volume environments.

See more

Overload Point

What is the overload point?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The SPL level where overload occurs.

Output Level

What is the output level?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The output voltage relative to input pressure.

Frequency Response (Min)

What is the minimum frequency response?

50 Hz 0 Votes
Fender P-51
50 Hz 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone has a minimum frequency response of 50 Hz, indicating its ability to capture lower-end bass frequencies.

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 has a frequency response range starting at 50 Hz, which helps capture the low-end frequencies of most vocal and instrument sounds.

The lowest frequency the mic can capture.

Frequency Response (Max)

What is the maximum frequency response?

15,000 Hz 0 Votes
Fender P-51
15,000 Hz 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone's maximum frequency response is 15000 Hz, which covers a wide range of audible high frequencies.

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58's frequency response reaches up to 15,000 Hz, ensuring it picks up all relevant vocal frequencies without distortion.

The highest frequency the mic can capture.

Voice Isolation Feature

Does it have voice isolation?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 1 Votes Shure SM58

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The cardioid pattern effectively isolates the voice from surrounding noise, perfect for live and studio recording.

Whether the mic includes isolation tech.

Voice isolation is a must-have for my recording setup. The Shure SM58 clearly has this advantage over the Fender P-51, which seems to lack this feature.

See more

Microphone Type

What is the microphone type?

26 Fender P-51 0 Votes Dynamic

50 Shure SM58 0 Votes Dynamic

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

This microphone is a Dynamic type, which is well-suited for live performances and high sound pressure levels due to its robust design.

Defines the operating principle of the microphone.

Capsule Type

What is the capsule type?

67 Fender P-51 0 Votes Large Diaphragm

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Capsule Type

Capsule Type is Large Diaphragm for Fender P-51 and unavailable for Shure SM58, indicating more capsule detail on P-51.

Specifies the capsule style that influences sound capture.

Output Impedance

What is the output impedance?

600 ohm 0 Votes
Fender P-51
150 ohm 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Output Impedance

Output Impedance is 600 ohm for Fender P-51 and 150 ohm for Shure SM58; the SM58 has lower impedance beneficial for longer cable runs.

Electrical resistance of the microphone’s output.

Stereo/Mono Mode

What mode is supported?

26 Fender P-51 0 Votes Mono

10 Shure SM58 0 Votes Mono

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Stereo/Mono Mode

Stereo/Mono Mode is Mono for both microphones, typical for handheld mics.

Determines recording mode.

Acoustic Principle

What is the acoustic principle?

96 Fender P-51 0 Votes Pressure Gradient

60 Shure SM58 0 Votes Pressure Gradient

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

This microphone uses a pressure gradient principle to capture sound efficiently, ensuring high audio quality.

The underlying sound capture mechanism.

Connectivity & Interfaces 15

Connection Interface

What is the connection interface?

36 Fender P-51 0 Votes XLR

20 Shure SM58 0 Votes XLR

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone uses a standard XLR connection, ensuring compatibility with professional audio equipment like mixers and interfaces.

Defines the main interface for connectivity.

Ground Lift Switch

Does it have a ground lift switch?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

There is no ground lift switch on the SM58, as it does not require one due to its analog design.

Prevents ground loop hum in audio systems.

Interface Latency

What is the interface latency?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Latency introduced by the interface.

Balanced/Unbalanced Output

What is the output type?

96 Fender P-51 0 Votes Balanced

85 Shure SM58 0 Votes Balanced

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Balanced/Unbalanced Output

Balanced/Unbalanced Output is Balanced for both microphones, offering noise-resistant connections.

Defines the type of electrical signal output.

Cable Detachable

Is the cable detachable?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether the cable can be detached or replaced.

Wireless Technology

What wireless technology is used?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The wireless system type used.

Bluetooth Version

What Bluetooth version does it support?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Version of Bluetooth supported (if applicable).

RF Frequency Range

What is the RF frequency range?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Frequency spectrum range for mics.

USB Compatibility

What USB versions are compatible?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Identifies supported USB standards.

Audio Output Options

What are the audio output options?

21 Fender P-51 0 Votes Unbalanced

88 Shure SM58 0 Votes Analog, Balanced

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Audio Output Options

Audio Output Options are Unbalanced for Fender P-51 and Analog, Balanced for Shure SM58, indicating SM58 offers balanced output benefiting noise reduction.

Lists output signal formats available.

Phantom Power Support

Does it support phantom power?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether the mic supports phantom power.

Multi-Device Pairing

Does it support multi-device pairing?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Multi-Device Pairing

Multi-Device Pairing is unavailable for Fender P-51 and No for Shure SM58, no multi-pairing.

Ability to connect to multiple devices simultaneously.

Power & Battery 12

Power Source

What is the power source?

16 Fender P-51 0 Votes Passive

90 Shure SM58 0 Votes Passive

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

As a Passive microphone, it does not require external power such as phantom power or batteries to operate. This is characteristic of dynamic microphones.

Defines how the microphone is powered.

Battery Life

What is the battery life?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

How long the microphone operates per charge.

Phantom Power Requirement

What is the phantom power requirement?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Specifies the phantom power voltage needed.

Battery Type

What is the battery type?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The type of battery used if portable.

Battery Capacity

What is the battery capacity?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Storage capacity of the built-in battery.

Recharge Time

What is the recharge time?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Time required to fully recharge the battery.

Power Consumption

What is the power consumption?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Amount of power drawn during use.

Auto Power-Off

Does it have auto power-off?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether the microphone shuts down automatically when idle.

Charging Method

What is the charging method?

35 Fender P-51 0 Votes USB Type-B

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The interface used for recharging.

Replaceable Battery Support

Does it support replaceable batteries?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates if batteries can be swapped.

External Power Supply Compatibility

Is it compatible with an external power supply?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
External Power Supply Compatibility

External Power Supply Compatibility is unavailable for Fender P-51 and No for Shure SM58, no external power support.

Can the mic run on external AC/DC supply.

Power Indicator Light

Does it have a power indicator light?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a light shows power/battery status.

Controls & Features 18

Headphone Monitoring

Does it support headphone monitoring?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

As a dynamic microphone, the SM58 does not include headphone monitoring.

Direct monitoring via headphone output.

Gain Control

Does it have gain control?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Ability to adjust input gain directly.

Monitoring Mix Control

Does it have monitoring mix control?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 does not have a built-in monitoring mix control.

Lets user adjust mic vs playback audio mix.

On/Off Switch

Does it include an on/off switch?

Yes 1 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether the microphone includes a physical on/off switch.

I really appreciate a physical on/off switch for quick control during live gigs. The Fender P-51 has it, but the Shure SM58 doesn't, which is a bit inconvenient for me.

See more

Onboard Controls

What onboard controls are available?

54 Fender P-51 0 Votes Buttons

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Onboard Controls

Onboard Controls are Buttons for Fender P-51 and unavailable for Shure SM58, P-51 offering physical control buttons.

Types of direct physical controls.

Mute Function

Does it have a mute function?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Ability to mute audio directly on the mic.

Touch/Motion Controls

Does it support touch/motion controls?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Allows interaction via touch gestures or motion.

LED Indicator Lights

Does it have LED indicators?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
LED Indicator Lights

LED Indicator Lights are unavailable for both microphones, no visual indicators.

Lights that show status such as mute, levels, or power.

App/Software Integration

Is it integrated with software/apps?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Works with companion apps or software.

EQ Presets

Does it have EQ presets?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Pre-configured equalization modes.

Voice Effects

Does it include voice effects?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Built-in voice modulation effects.

Feedback Suppression

Does it have feedback suppression?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Prevents audio feedback loops in live use.

Build & Design 18

Water Resistance

Is it water resistant?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Water Resistance

Water Resistance is unavailable for Fender P-51 and No for Shure SM58, no water protection.

Indicates if the mic is resistant to water.

Internal Dampening Material

What is the internal dampening material?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

78 Shure SM58 0 Votes Foam

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Internal Dampening Material

Internal Dampening Material is unavailable for Fender P-51 and Foam for Shure SM58, enhancing SM58's internal noise reduction.

The material used internally to reduce noise/vibration.

Internal Shockmount

Is there an internal shockmount for the capsule?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Internal Shockmount

Internal Shockmount is Yes for both Fender P-51 and Shure SM58, improving mechanical vibration isolation.

Capsule isolation that reduces handling noise.

Grill Material

What is the grill material?

0 Fender P-51 0 Votes Metal

80 Shure SM58 0 Votes Steel

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone features a Metal grill, which protects the capsule from physical damage and helps reduce plosives.

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 features a durable steel mesh grille that protects the microphone capsule from physical damage.

The material of the protective mic grill.

Body Material

What is the body material?

56 Fender P-51 0 Votes Metal

88 Shure SM58 0 Votes Metal

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Body Material

Body Material is Metal for both microphones, ensuring durability.

The main structural material of the microphone body.

Adjustable Arm/Stand

Does it have an adjustable arm/stand?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone comes with an adjustable arm or stand. This enhances versatility for positioning during performances or recording.

Whether the arm/stand can be adjusted.

Detachable Mount

Is the mount detachable?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone features a detachable mount. This allows for easy attachment and removal from various stands or clips.

If the mount can be detached for flexibility.

Finish/Coating

What finish/coating does it have?

0 Fender P-51 0 Votes Rugged Metal

85 Shure SM58 0 Votes Matte

Exterior treatment or surface finish.

Shock Mount

Is a shock mount included?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a shock mount is included to reduce vibrations.

Pop Filter

Is a pop filter included?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a pop filter is provided for plosive reduction.

Windscreen

Is a windscreen included?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a windscreen is included for wind noise control.

Dust Resistance

Is it dust resistant?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates if the mic is resistant to dust.

Package & Accessories 13

Stand/Tripod

Is a stand/tripod included?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a stand or tripod is included in the box.

Adapters

Are adapters included?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

States if adapter(s) are included (e.g., XLR to 3.5mm).

Optional Windshield Model

What is the recommended windshield model?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

75 Shure SM58 0 Votes A58WS

Manufacturer-recommended windshield model.

Cables

Are cables included?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

The microphone kit includes necessary cables. This ensures you have all essential components for immediate setup.

Indicates if connecting cables are provided.

Carrying Case

Is there a carrying case included?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Carrying Case

Carrying Case is Yes for both microphones, helping portability.

Whether a protective carrying case is part of the package.

Spare Parts Availability

Are spare parts available?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Spare Parts Availability

Spare Parts Availability is Yes for both microphones, supporting long-term maintenance.

Whether the manufacturer provides replacement parts.

Mounting Clip

Is a mounting clip included?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Mounting Clip

Mounting Clip is Yes for both microphones, useful for positioning.

Whether a clip for attaching to stands/instruments is included.

Extra Windscreen

Is an extra windscreen included?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Extra Windscreen

Extra Windscreen is unavailable for Fender P-51 and No for Shure SM58, no extra wind protection included.

Indicates if a spare windscreen is included.

Instruction Manual

Is an instruction manual included?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a manual or quick-start guide is included.

Packaging Type

What is the packaging type?

0 Fender P-51 0 Votes Box

80 Shure SM58 0 Votes Box

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Packaging Type

Packaging Type is Box for both microphones, standard retail packaging.

Defines how the product is packaged.

Stickers/Branding

Are stickers/branding included?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Stickers/Branding

Stickers/Branding is unavailable for Fender P-51 and No for Shure SM58, no extra branding stickers.

Indicates if stickers or branded items are in the package.

Warranty Card

Is a warranty card included?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a warranty card is included.

Certification & Compliance 7

Environmental Compliance

Is it environmentally compliant?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
Fender P-51

This product is compliant with environmental regulations.

Compliance with eco/environmental regulations.

FCC/CE Approval

Is it FCC/CE approved?

Yes 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
FCC/CE Approval

FCC/CE Approval is Yes for both microphones, ensuring regulatory compliance.

Explicit FCC/CE compliance approval.

Warranty

What is the warranty period?

5 years 1 Votes
Fender P-51
2 years 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Duration of manufacturer warranty coverage.

A longer warranty is always a plus in my book. The Fender P-51 offering 5 years of warranty gives me more peace of mind than the Shure SM58's 2 years.

See more

Professional Broadcast Certification

Is it broadcast certified?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 1 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates if the mic meets pro broadcast standards.

For professional broadcast certification, the Shure SM58 is the clear winner here. It's crucial for my work to have that official backing, which the Fender P-51 doesn't offer.

See more

Safety Compliance

Is it safety compliant?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates adherence to safety regulations.

RoHS Compliance

Is it RoHS compliant?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Restriction of Hazardous Substances directive compliance.

Temperature Range (Operating)

What is the operating temperature range?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

80 Shure SM58 0 Votes 0° to 122°F

Operating temperature window for reliable use.

Advanced Features 15

Beamforming Technology

Does it support beamforming?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Uses mic arrays to focus on sound sources.

Voice Tracking

Does it include voice tracking?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Automatically follows speaker’s voice.

Recording Profiles

Does it have recording profiles?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Predefined sound settings for specific uses.

Multi-Pattern Switching

Does it support multi-pattern switching?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Ability to switch between multiple pickup patterns.

DSP Processing

Does it include DSP processing?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
DSP Processing

DSP Processing is unavailable for both microphones, no digital signal processing features.

Built-in digital signal processing for sound shaping.

AI Noise Cancellation

Does it feature AI noise cancellation?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

AI-powered suppression of background noise.

Surround Capture Mode

Does it support surround capture?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Ability to capture immersive 360° or surround sound.

Auto Calibration

Does it support auto calibration?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Automatically adjusts mic response to environment.

Low Latency Monitoring

Does it support low-latency monitoring?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Provides near real-time monitoring with minimal delay.

Smart Assistant Compatibility

Is it compatible with smart assistants?

Who knows? 0 Votes Fender P-51 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Integration with voice assistants.

Cloud Profile Storage

Does it support cloud profile storage?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Fender P-51
vs
Shure SM58
Cloud Profile Storage

Cloud Profile Storage is unavailable for both microphones, no cloud sync features.

Saves mic settings to the cloud.

Firmware Upgrade Support

Does it support firmware upgrades?

No 0 Votes Fender P-51

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Ability to update functionality via firmware.

Surveys

Because hot takes deserve votes.

Sound Quality

How would you rate the sound quality of this microphone?

Crisp and professional
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Good and clear
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Average clarity
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Distorted and unclear
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Noise Handling

How well does this microphone handle background noise?

Blocks out most noise
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Handles noise fairly well
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Reduces some noise
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Picks up everything
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Battery Life

How long does the battery last on this microphone?

Excellent — Over 20 hours
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Long lasting — 10 to 20 hours
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Decent — 5 to 10 hours
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Short — 2 to 5 hours
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Very short — Under 2 hours
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Durability

How durable is this microphone based on build and lifespan?

Highly durable — Over 4 years
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Solid — 2 to 4 years
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Average — 1 to 2 years
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Very fragile — Less than 1 year
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Weight

How heavy is this microphone?

Ultra-light — Under 150 grams
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Lightweight — 150 to 300 grams
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Medium — 300 to 500 grams
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Heavy — 500 to 800 grams
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Very heavy — Over 800 grams
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Design Appeal

How attractive is the design of this microphone?

Plain and boring
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Somewhat okay
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Nice looking
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Stylish and modern
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Pricing

How do you feel about the price of this microphone?

Great value for money
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Pretty good price
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Fair deal
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Kinda pricey
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Crazy expensive
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Sensitivity

How sensitive is this microphone to capturing sound?

Very sensitive — Detects quiet sounds clearly
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Sensitive — Captures a wide sound range
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Moderate — Picks up normal voice levels well
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Low — Needs to be close to sound source
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Very low — Struggles to capture soft voices
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Frequency Response Range

What do you think about the frequency response range of this microphone?

Wide range — 20 Hz to 20 kHz
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Good range — 30 Hz to 18 kHz
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Decent range — 40 Hz to 16 kHz
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Limited range — 50 Hz to 14 kHz
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Narrow range — Above 60 Hz only
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Connectivity

How stable and reliable is the connection of this microphone?

Excellent — Always stable, no dropouts
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Good — Works smoothly with rare issues
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Decent — Occasional minor disconnections
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Weak — Disconnects sometimes
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Poor — Frequently loses connection
0 Votes
Fender P-51
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Guides 2

Videos 1

Fender P-51 Manual

Fender P-51 Manual

youtube.com
youtube.com

Articles 1

Shure SM58 Manual

Shure SM58 Manual

shure.com
shure.com

Reviews 0

The good, the bad, and the brutally honest.

Average Rating

Fender
Fender
Fender P-51
Fender P-51
0 / 5 0 Reviews
Shure
Shure
Shure SM58
Shure SM58
0 / 5 0 Reviews

Discussions 0

Thoughts, takes, and hot debates.

Awards 4

Only the best made it here.

Collections 0

Treasures You’ve picked. No fluff, all fun.

More Microphones 0

Unlock more awesome finds.

Other Fender Microphones 0

Other Shure Microphones 76

Fender P-51
Fender
Fender
Fender P-51
Shure SM58
Shure
Shure
Shure SM58
vs